You’ve polished your resume and filled it with keywords. You’ve included metrics driven bullet points about how you “increased sales by 27%” or “saved the company $160k”. And still, you’re not landing a job offer.
Because hiring managers are evaluating more than what’s written on your resume. In fact, some of the biggest green (or red) flags they see come after they’ve skimmed your work history. Let’s take a closer look and talk about the things hiring managers are really paying attention to.
1. Your Communication Style
Every email, phone call, and message you send is being evaluated, whether you realize it or not. Typos, disorganized thoughts, or one-word replies can create a lasting impression. Yes, something as simple as that can turn away hiring managers!
Hiring managers are assessing:
- How clearly you express yourself.
- Whether you’re professional and personable.
- If you respond in a timely and respectful way.
I’ve seen incredible resumes fail because the candidate wrote like they were texting their roommate. On the other hand, a mediocre resume can get attention if the candidate is articulate and easy to talk to.
2. Your Level of Curiosity
Hiring managers love candidates who ask smart questions, and not just at the end of an interview, but throughout the process. It shows you’re invested, you’ve done your research, and you’re thinking critically about whether this job is actually the right fit.
Some great signs of curiosity:
- Asking about team dynamics, workflow, or company strategy.
- Following up on something mentioned earlier in the conversation.
- Showing genuine interest in the business, not just the job description.
If you’re just saying “sounds good” to everything, that’s a red flag. Nobody wants to hire someone who just wants a job. They want someone who’s thoughtfully choosing this job, whether it’s true or not.
3. How You Talk About Past Employers
This one is subtle, but it matters a lot. Hiring managers listen very closely to how you describe your previous roles, and more importantly, how you talk about your past teams and bosses.
Are you always the hero of the story? Is everything someone else’s fault? This can easily be an immediate red flag and it’s an extremely easy thing to notice.
Hiring managers look for signs of:
- Emotional intelligence.
- Self-awareness.
- Ability to take ownership without throwing others under the bus.
Even if your last job was a dumpster fire, you can say that tactfully. “There were some leadership challenges” lands a lot better than complaining during an interview about how bad your last manager was.
4. Consistency Across Platforms
You’d be surprised how many hiring managers Google you. LinkedIn, social media, personal websites, they’re fair game. If your resume says one thing but your online presence says another, that raises eyebrows.
A few examples:
- Your resume says you’re still working at a company you left 6 months ago.
- Your LinkedIn job titles don’t match your resume.
- Your Twitter is just memes and arguments.
You don’t have to be a social media saint, but inconsistency makes hiring managers wonder what else you might be misrepresented.
5. Your Attitude Toward Feedback
This doesn’t show up on paper, but it shows up fast in interviews, especially if you’re asked situational questions or given feedback in real time.
Hiring managers are watching for:
- Defensiveness vs. openness.
- Willingness to learn or adjust.
- Ability to handle critique without getting upset.
One of the best soft skills a person can bring to a team is coachability. You don’t need to be perfect! There are countless times where I’ve decided against a particular candidate because they acted as though they already knew everything. This type of attitude is very off-putting and makes hiring managers feel like you would be hard to train and work with.
6. Your Timing and Follow-Up
Hiring is a messy process. Calendars shift and priorities change. But one thing hiring managers always remember? The candidates who follow up!
What they look for:
- Candidates who follow up once (not seven times).
- Thank-you notes that are specific and thoughtful.
- People who can express continued interest without sounding desperate.
Good follow-up shows you care. Great follow-up shows you’re professional, self-aware, and genuinely enthusiastic about the role. It’s also a great time to communicate any extra questions you had! I know I’ve immediately thought of something I forgot to ask the second I finished a phone screen.
7. Your Energy
This one’s hard to define, but easy to feel. Like it or not, hiring managers are humans. They sometimes make decisions solely based on vibe.
That doesn’t mean you need to be an extrovert or put on a show. But it does mean:
- You should be engaged, not checked out.
- You should sound excited somewhere in your voice.
- You should seem like someone who’s ready to do the job, not just get the offer.
Sometimes, the deciding factor between two equally qualified candidates comes down to energy: who seemed like they’d be great to work with on a Tuesday afternoon when everything’s on fire.
8. Your Understanding of the Role
Believe it or not, one of the biggest reasons candidates are passed on isn’t lack of skills, but a lack of understanding about what the role actually is.
Hiring managers want to know:
- Did you actually read the job description?
- Do you understand what this role solves for the business?
- Are you aware of how this role connects to the team’s or company’s goals?
When a candidate shows they “get it,” it makes everything easier. It becomes less about what they’ve done in the past and more about how they’ll solve problems going forward. It looks terrible when you ask a question during the interview about the job that would be obvious if you actually read the job description.
So… Does Your Resume Even Matter?
Yes, your resume still matters. It’s your foot in the door. But it’s just one piece of the puzzle.
The truth is, how you present yourself, starting from the first email to the final handshake, carries just as much weight. Hiring managers want the full picture: skills, attitude, communication, consistency, and potential.
So before you send off that next application, ask yourself:
- Am I telling a consistent story across all platforms?
- Am I ready to talk about my past without sounding bitter?
- Am I showing genuine interest and curiosity?
- Am I easy to communicate with?
If you can answer yes to those, you’re already doing more than most. And hiring managers? They’ll notice
Yes! Hiring managers care about more than just what’s written on paper. Strong communication, curiosity, and a clear understanding of the role can outweigh a less than perfect resume. Many candidates are chosen based on potential, not perfection.
A poor attitude! Especially around feedback or past employers. If you come off as defensive, blame others for everything, or act like you’re above learning, it raises major concerns about how you’ll function on a team.
Show up prepared, engaged, and curious. Be sure to ask thoughtful questions, show you understand the business, and bring good energy to the conversation. Those intangibles are often what tip the scales in your favor.
See Also
